
Compare a mixed 1688 order with a full carton for your Malaysian shop. A ringgit worksheet shows how to allocate freight, account for unsellable pieces and see the extra cash each order ties up.

Ask the 1688 seller to price the same product two ways before you commit your ringgit. If the supplier allows it, a mixed lot lets you choose a combination of colours, sizes or models; with a full carton you accept the supplier’s stated pack and colour ratio. Compare what you will spend to get each sellable piece to your Malaysian shop, then look at how much cash the order takes. A cheaper piece can still be an expensive way to fill a shelf with the wrong colour.
Put the two carton offers on one sheet
Suppose you sell fabric pencil pouches in a few colours. For the mixed offer, ask whether the minimum applies to the order, to each colour or to each design. For the full carton, ask how many of each colour it contains. A quote for “one carton” leaves both your unit count and your stock mix open.
Give both sellers the same Malaysian delivery postcode and delivery scope. A quote ending at a collection depot and one ending at your shop need a separate last-mile line before you can compare them. Ask for the domestic Chinese delivery fee, packed dimensions, gross weight, pieces per carton and any packing charge. Note which figures are estimates. If someone else pays the 1688 supplier, agree who can approve substitutions and who receives a refund. The Malaysian first-order guide to payment and refunds explains that decision.
Compare the cash outlay with ringgit per sellable piece
Hypothetical worksheet. The prices, exchange rate, quantities and allowances below are invented for the calculation; they are not supplier quotations, freight rates or tax rates. Both offers are for the same pouch and end at the same shop. The allowance is included once.
| Entry | Mixed colours | Full carton |
|---|---|---|
| Pieces ordered | 50 | 72 |
| Estimated sellable pieces after checking | 48 | 70 |
| Goods + delivery to the China warehouse | CNY 600 + 40 | CNY 800 + 40 |
| Converted at the assumed RM0.65 per CNY | RM416 | RM546 |
| International freight, handling and delivery | RM112 | RM170 |
| Allowance for applicable charges not already paid | RM32 | RM40 |
| Total to the shop | RM560 | RM756 |
| Total ÷ sellable pieces | RM11.67 | RM10.80 |
The full carton ties up another RM196 for 22 more sellable pieces. If it contains more of the colour you already struggle to sell, look at your actual weekly sales of that colour before releasing the extra money. An intact slow seller remains stock. A pouch that cannot be sold belongs in the loss count until a replacement or credit is confirmed. Before purchase, use an explicitly labelled estimate for losses; after inspection, enter the actual count.
If your mixed carton carries different products
Use separate lines for each SKU (the specific model, size or colour you stock). Enter its actual CNY price less confirmed discounts or refunds. For your final calculation, convert at the rate you actually paid and record any payment fee once. When a forwarder charged by volume, share that freight in proportion to the packed space each SKU used. Where the bill is by actual weight, use each SKU’s share of the billed weight. Identical pouches packed the same way can reasonably share costs by count. Apply a charge specific to one item, such as protective packaging, directly to that item.
For each SKU divide its goods cost plus its allocated charges by its own verified sellable quantity. If a whole SKU failed inspection, record that loss separately; leave its unit cost blank until you agree a remedy. Keep a separate line for your marketplace commission, local customer delivery and returns if you later use this cost to set a retail price.
Decide what belongs in the Malaysian tax line
Malaysia’s Customs Department explains that for qualifying online goods sold for RM500 or less, registered sellers charge 10% sales tax on low-value goods (LVG) on the sale value, excluding freight and insurance. The qualifying sale may arrive by land, sea or air. A separate air-courier de minimis provision uses the consignment’s cost, insurance and freight. A carton of small items can cross that consignment threshold even when each item is inexpensive. Keep the invoice and seller registration details if LVG was charged; ask the importer or customs agent to match that evidence to the goods before recording a second tax charge. Royal Malaysian Customs LVG FAQ
For a commercial restock, give your customs agent the item description, material, intended use, origin and invoice. Ask for the applicable tariff classification, import taxes and any approvals, then revise the allowance using the actual documents. A fabric pouch and a device sold with a battery should not share an assumed tariff or permit decision. Review the Malaysian Customs tariff lookup against the actual item before shipment. Rules checked on 20 November 2026.
What to send before you pay
“Please quote a mixed order and a sealed full carton of this exact model. List the quantity and price of each colour, permitted substitutions, domestic delivery, packed size and weight, and how long each quote is valid. Please confirm which charges reach my Malaysian postcode.”
If you use 1688 purchasing assistance, specify which counts and visible details you need photographed at the China warehouse. Once the actual cartons arrive, update the quantities and measurements before approving forwarding. A warehouse photo can help verify the colour mix; a functional test, customs classification or import permit calls for a separate check.
📲 Download the YDA Express App
Use the YDA Express App to place China purchasing orders, view product check photos, manage packages, and arrange consolidation and international forwarding.
